Warm, handcrafted cookies baked with heartfelt passion in New York.
Welcome to Simply Cookies NYC. Discover our small-batch homemade cookies, seasonal holiday treats, and artisanal baked goods. Order your favorites online for doorstep delivery or find our upcoming weekend vendor pop-up locations.
Fresh from the Oven
Explore our bestselling homemade cookies and seasonal treats, baked in small batches and ready for quick online ordering or local vendor pickup.
How our fresh treats arrive at your door
Whether you want cookies shipped directly to your home across the country, prefer local NYC bakery pickup, or love visiting our weekend pop-up tables, we make getting fresh batches quick and delightful.
Browse our seasonal menu online, choose your favorite cookie flavors, and select a 6-pack or 12-pack gift box.
Choose your preferred shipping date at checkout. We package each batch with food-safe parchment and insulated seal.
Your order arrives sealed with reheating guidelines for warm, gooey centers and crisp bakery edges.
Explore our current batch of signature cookies, seasonal fruit tarts, and limited gift boxes.
Baking joy that sparks genuine smiles
From our neighborhood market pop-up tables to doorstep deliveries across town, here is what our cookie community has to say.
"Absolutely love the seasonal cookies! Always fresh and beautifully decorated."
The holiday spiced sugar cookies are now a mandatory tradition in our household.
Jane D.
Happy Customer
"The online ordering process is so smooth, and the treats are irresistible."
Packaged with such care and arrived perfectly crisp on the edges and soft in the center.
Mark S.
Loyal Customer
"Received a curated gift box from a friend in Brooklyn and finished the entire tin in two days."
You can genuinely taste the wholesome butter and pure vanilla in every single bite.
Elena R.
Gift Recipient